S’mores Girl Scout Cookies are more than just a seasonal sweet—they’re a bite of nostalgia that’s captured hearts across the country. If you’ve ever waited all year just to get your hands on a box of s’mores Girl Scout Cookies, you’re not alone. These toasty, chocolatey treats have earned a special place in snack lovers’ hearts—especially for those of us with childhood memories tied to sticky marshmallows and graham crackers around the campfire. In this article, we’re diving into the story of these cookies, why they’re so loved, and what’s going on with their availability. You’ll learn the history behind them, what made them unique, and what to do if you can’t find them anymore.
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
The First Time I Tried One: A Nostalgic Bite
It was early spring, and I had just picked up a few boxes of Girl Scout Cookies from the troop down the street. One of them was labeled “S’mores,” and I didn’t think much of it—until I took a bite. That mix of crunchy graham, gooey-style marshmallow, and chocolatey coating instantly reminded me of summer nights camping with my cousins. The flavor was rich but not overly sweet, and unlike any other cookie in the lineup. It quickly became my go-to, even before the classic Thin Mints or Samoas.
The beauty of s’mores Girl Scout Cookies wasn’t just the flavor—it was the experience packed into each bite. For many of us, they offered a mini flashback to childhood. That’s why it hit hard when rumors started swirling that they might be discontinued. At first, I brushed it off. But year after year, they started getting harder to find.
Print
S’mores Girl Scout Cookies: Why We Loved Them and Where They Went
- Total Time: 25 minutes
- Yield: 12 cookies 1x
- Diet: Vegetarian
Description
This homemade take on the nostalgic s’mores Girl Scout Cookies brings together crisp graham crackers, sweet marshmallow crème, and rich chocolate coating—all made from scratch or with easy store-bought ingredients.
Ingredients
1 sleeve graham crackers (about 8 full sheets)
1 cup marshmallow crème (or fluff)
1/2 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
1/2 cup milk chocolate chips
1 tsp coconut oil (optional, for smoother coating)
Instructions
1. Break graham crackers into squares and line them on a parchment-covered tray.
2. Spread a layer of marshmallow crème on half the squares.
3. Top with another cracker to form a sandwich.
4. Melt both types of chocolate chips in a microwave-safe bowl in 30-second intervals, stirring until smooth.
5. Stir in coconut oil for easier coating (optional).
6. Dip each sandwich completely in melted chocolate using tongs.
7. Place dipped cookies on tray and refrigerate for 30 minutes or until chocolate sets.
8. Store in an airtight container at room temperature or refrigerate if preferred.
Notes
Use vegan marshmallow crème and chocolate to make it dairy-free.
You can freeze the cookies for longer storage.
Try dark chocolate for a less sweet finish.
- Prep Time: 20 minutes
- Cook Time: 5 minutes
- Category: Dessert
- Method: No-Bake
- Cuisine: American
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1 cookie
- Calories: 180
- Sugar: 14g
- Sodium: 65mg
- Fat: 9g
- Saturated Fat: 5g
- Unsaturated Fat: 3g
- Trans Fat: 0g
- Carbohydrates: 23g
- Fiber: 1g
- Protein: 1g
- Cholesterol: 0mg
A Cookie with Two Versions: Why It Was Confusing
Most people don’t know this, but there were actually two different versions of s’mores Girl Scout Cookies—depending on where you lived. Girl Scouts USA works with two licensed bakeries: ABC Bakers and Little Brownie Bakers. Each bakery made its own version of the cookie. ABC’s was a crunchy graham sandwich with a marshmallow and chocolate layer inside. Little Brownie’s was a dipped cookie, fully coated in chocolate with that signature s’mores taste.
While both aimed to capture the flavor of a traditional s’more, they looked and tasted different. That caused some confusion. People in one region might rave about s’mores Girl Scout Cookies, while someone in another region would wonder what all the fuss was about. Despite the variations, one thing was consistent—demand was strong, especially as word spread on social media.
Why You Can’t Find S’mores Girl Scout Cookies Anymore
The Quiet Goodbye: Are S’mores Girl Scout Cookies Discontinued?
Yes—sadly, they are. If you’ve been wondering why you haven’t spotted s’mores Girl Scout Cookies on the order form this year, you’re not imagining it. In 2023, Girl Scouts of the USA confirmed that both versions of the s’mores cookies were retired. The decision was made quietly, with very little public announcement, which left many cookie fans surprised when their favorite flavor suddenly vanished.
Why were they discontinued? According to some local councils and troop leaders, the decision boiled down to production costs and logistics. Compared to other cookie flavors, the s’mores options were more complex and expensive to produce. Each bakery had to manage extra ingredients, special coatings, and packaging differences. In short, it became too much to manage on a national level.
While there hasn’t been one big official statement from Girl Scouts USA outlining every detail, the writing was on the wall. Troops began removing s’mores from their offerings, and the official cookie lineup no longer features them. For fans, it’s a tough loss—but not entirely unexpected in today’s changing supply and cost landscape.
Where Did They Go? Why You Can’t Find Them Now
Even if some stores or troop booths might still show past images, you’re unlikely to find boxes of s’mores Girl Scout Cookies this year. Some people have tried turning to resale sites, but most listings are either expired or overpriced. Others have wondered if they’re only “retired temporarily” like some seasonal snacks, but there’s no sign of a return just yet.
One key reason is that Girl Scout Cookies operate in a highly controlled sales window. If a cookie is pulled from the seasonal catalog, it’s not something you’ll just stumble upon later. So unless you know a troop that has a rare leftover stash (and let’s be honest, those go fast), they’re pretty much gone from shelves.
Some fans have even launched petitions and campaigns on social media to “bring back s’mores,” hoping to show how beloved the cookie really was. But for now, Girl Scouts are focusing on streamlining their core offerings and newer flavors like Toast-Yay! or Raspberry Rally, both of which have strong followings of their own.
What Made S’mores Cookies Special?o
Ask any fan, and they’ll tell you—s’mores Girl Scout Cookies weren’t just tasty; they were comforting. Whether it was the graham-cracker sandwich or the chocolate-dipped version, these cookies packed the warmth of a campfire treat into something shelf-stable and easy to enjoy year-round. That balance of texture, sweetness, and nostalgia was hard to beat.
For the Girl Scouts, it wasn’t just about flavor. The cookies were a clever nod to the organization’s roots. After all, s’mores are a staple of outdoor adventures, and the Girl Scouts helped popularize the treat back in the 1920s. Naming a cookie after it felt like a full-circle moment—merging tradition with modern cravings.
Even in a crowded lineup filled with favorites like Tagalongs and Do-si-dos, the s’mores cookies carved out their place. They became the cookie that parents and kids both looked forward to—one that felt just a little more indulgent and special. That’s why their departure hit so many fans right in the sweet tooth.
Alternatives You Can Try (That Actually Taste Like S’mores)
Now that s’mores Girl Scout Cookies are off the market, the question becomes: what can you grab instead? While no substitute will feel quite the same, there are a few grocery-store options that come surprisingly close.
| Brand/Product | S’mores Style |
|---|---|
| Keebler Fudge Stripe S’mores | Graham cookies dipped in fudge with a marshmallowy center |
| Great Value S’mores Sandwich Cookies (Walmart) | Layered cookie with chocolate and marshmallow flavor filling |
| Stuffed Puffs Filled Marshmallows | Not a cookie, but makes great homemade s’mores with no mess |
| Hostess S’mores Cupcakes | A richer take with marshmallow filling and graham-flavored cak |
If you’re feeling ambitious, you can always try making your own homemade version inspired by the cookie. Use graham crackers, a marshmallow spread, and dip them in melted chocolate. Store them in the fridge, and you’ve got a quick DIY treat that might hit the same nostalgic note.
FAQs About S’mores Girl Scout Cookies
Before we wrap things up, let’s answer some of the most common questions about the beloved s’mores Girl Scout Cookies. These are the ones that have sparked the most curiosity (and frustration) online since the cookies quietly disappeared.
Are s’mores Girl Scout Cookies discontinued?
Yes, they are. Both bakery versions—one coated in chocolate and one as a graham sandwich—have been officially retired. The Girl Scouts haven’t released a detailed explanation, but production complexity and cost likely played a big role. Many fans were disappointed to see them vanish from the seasonal order form in 2023, and they haven’t returned since.
Why can’t I find s’mores Girl Scout Cookies?
If you’ve been checking your local troop’s cookie list or refreshing the online store to no avail, it’s because s’mores Girl Scout Cookies are no longer part of the lineup. They were discontinued quietly, with very little official fanfare. You might still spot images or old mentions online, but those are just leftovers from previous seasons. Right now, there’s no sign of a comeback.
What are the S’mores Girl Scout Cookies?
S’mores cookies were introduced in 2017 to celebrate 100 years of Girl Scouts selling cookies. Depending on your region, you got one of two styles:
ABC Bakers: A graham cracker sandwich with marshmallow and chocolate crème filling.
Little Brownie Bakers: A graham cookie dipped entirely in crème icing and covered in a chocolatey coating.
Both styles aimed to capture the campfire treat in cookie form—and both were well-loved in their own way.
Why are they retiring s’mores?
The short answer? Production costs and complications. Having two different cookie types under one name made logistics tricky. Plus, the ingredients and baking processes were more involved than simpler cookies like Trefoils or Thin Mints. With supply chain pressures and cost increases, it’s likely that the Girl Scouts decided to focus on streamlining their offerings.
Final Thoughts
The loss of s’mores Girl Scout Cookies feels like more than just the end of a flavor—it’s the end of a cookie that brought together nostalgia, creativity, and connection to the Girl Scouts’ outdoorsy roots. Whether you miss the marshmallowy center or the full chocolatey coating, you’re definitely not alone.
Luckily, a few solid alternatives exist on grocery store shelves. And if you’re feeling a little kitchen-curious, this might be the perfect excuse to try making your own version. Sometimes the best recipes are born from the ones we miss most.
